The ruling that lays bare the gross injustice of the three strikes law

The court said a prison sentence was ‘manifestly unjust’, but it had no alternative, explains Andrew Geddis. In some New Zealand prison sits a man called Daniel Clinton Fitzgerald. He has been behind bars since December of 2016. Unless something happens, of which more later, he may stay there until December 2023. All because he … Read more

A brief history of New Zealand’s most absurd three-strikes cases

As the government is forced into retreat over its planned repeal of the three strikes law, it’s worth remembering just why it needs to go. The government’s plan to repeal the three strikes law may be dead (for now), but as long as it stays on the books, the reasons for the initial impetus to … Read more

The Bulletin: Winston flexes ahead of taking top job

Good morning, and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Winston Peters makes moves ahead of top job tenure, Afghanistan deployment extended, and Christchurch mulls AirBnb rates.  It could be days, it could be weeks, but regardless, NZ First leader Winston Peters is about to take on the role of acting Prime Minister. And he appears to … Read more

The Bulletin: Pump up the fuel tax

Good morning, welcome to winter, and and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Auckland Council passes 10 year budget, National hates Labour’s sentencing proposals, and a concerning glimpse of the culture at Tauranga hospital.  Auckland’s ten year budget has made it through Council, meaning spending and rates plans for the next decade can be locked … Read more

That High Court judge, translated: ‘This three-strikes law is batshit crazy’

Faced with an absurdly rigid obligation to issue a prison sentence for a relatively minor offence, Justice Toogood deployed every drop of discretion available, writes Andrew Geddis New Zealand has had a “three strikes” sentencing regime in place for some six years now. At the time of its introduction, it was sold as a measure to … Read more